Double Jeopardy


Article I, § 9 of the Florida Constitution reads, “no person shall be twice put in jeopardy for the same offense.”  Similarly, the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides that “no person shall be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb.”  But what happens when a jury returns a verdict finding a defendant guilty of two criminal offenses having the same elements, but one which carries a lesser sentence than the other?  As seen, neither the United States Constitution nor the Florida Constitution dictate which conviction should be vacated.

This issue was recently addressed by the Florida Supreme Court in State of Florida v. Tuttle, SC14-817 (Nov. 12, 2015).  In Tuttle, a jury returned a verdict finding the defendant guilty of attempted home invasion burglary and armed burglary.  Before the trial court entered the sentencing phase, the State of Florida advised the court of the double jeopardy issue and requested that the court dismiss the attempted home invasion count as it carried a lesser sentence.  The defendant objected and advised that the court was required to dismiss the count carrying the higher potential sentence. 

The Florida Supreme Court accepted review of this issue as there was conflict regarding this issue amongst the First, Fourth and Fifth District Courts of Appeal.  The Florida Legislature has codified the double jeopardy test that was annunciated in Blockburger v. United States, 284 U.S. 299 (1932) in Florida Statute § 775.021(4).  This section provides as follows:

(b) The intent of the Legislature is to convict and sentence for each criminal offense committed in the course of one criminal episode or transaction and not to allow the principle of lenity as set forth in subsection (1) to determine legislative intent. Exceptions to this rule of construction are:

1. Offenses which require identical elements of proof.

2. Offenses which are degrees of the same offense as provided by statute.

3. Offenses which are lesser offenses the statutory elements of which are subsumed by the greater offense.

The Florida Supreme Court held, “that when a defendant is found guilty for two offenses and adjudication of the defendant as guilty for both offenses would violate double jeopardy and section 775.021(4)(b)3., the lesser offense as defined by Pizzo v. State, 945 So.2d 1203 (Fla. 2006) should be vacated.”
Location: 501 N Magnolia Ave, Orlando, FL 32801, USA

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Violation of Probation

          On April 21, 2016, the Florida Supreme Court granted review of the Second District Court of Appeals decision in Queior v. State , 157 So.3d 370 (Fla. 2DCA 2015) on the issue of whether a Probation Officer’s testimony that a probationer has failed a drug test administered by the Probation Officer is competent, non-hearsay evidence for purposes of proving a violation of probation .                In Queior , the State sought to revoke the defendant’s probation of the basis of a positive drug test.   At the hearing on the violation of probation , the State offered testimony from the defendant’s probation officer that they personally administered the drug test and that the test read positive.   The defense objected to the testimony claiming that the State had failed to lay the proper predicate to establish the reliability of the field drug test.   The trial court revoked the defendant’s probation.           The defendant appealed, and the Second District Court of Appeal r
Read more

Do I Need to Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney

Do I Need to Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney If you have been arrested or given a Notice to Appear in Court, it is a wise decision to seek the advice and counsel of an experienced criminal defense attorney .   Although there is no guarantee that the hiring of a lawyer will result in the dismissal of your case, a criminal lawyer can certainly have an impact on the outcome of the case and can guide you through the process to insure that your rights are protected. In criminal law, you can be charged with either a felony or misdemeanor offense.   A misdemeanor offense is one that is punishable by up to one-year in the county jail.   Although less serious than a felony offense, a misdemeanor can still have a major impact on your life.   Hiring the right criminal lawyer for your case might seem like an arduous task.   But taking the time to find the best lawyer can make a big difference.   When looking for a criminal defense lawyer, questions you should ask include:  how long have you
Read more

How Do I Find the Right Seminole County Criminal Defense Attorney

An arrest is not something that anyone ever plans for.  But when it happens, decisions must be made quickly.  Your first order of business is contacting a bondsman to get yourself out of jail.  Once this accomplished, your next order of business is finding a Seminole County Criminal Defense Lawyer to defend you.  Finding the best lawyer can make the difference in the outcome of your case.   First, find a lawyer that you can trust and communicate with.  Too often, I end up handling cases where clients come to me after finding that the lawyer they initially hired never returned their calls.  Communication is important.  Next, find a lawyer who focuses their practice on criminal defense.  Law Firms that tell you that they can help you with your criminal case, personal injury case, and family law case will not be a good fit.  When your liberties are at stake, you do not want a lawyer who primarily handles divorces and car accident cases sitting next to you in court.  Be sure that your lawy
Read more